Showing posts with label love. Show all posts
Showing posts with label love. Show all posts

Friday, 10 July 2026

Othello by William Shakespeare






1. Origin of Drama 

2. Basics of Drama (Othello) 

3. Tragedy 

4. William Shakespeare 


1. The Origin of Drama


(Figure 1. The Origin of Drama. Generated with ChatGPT (OpenAI) based on a user prompt by the researcher, July 2026.) 


Drama is a form of literature that is written to be performed on stage. The word "Drama" comes from the Greek word dran, which means "to act" or "to do." Drama began in Ancient Greece around the 6th century BCE during religious festivals dedicated to Dionysus, the Greek god of wine and theatre. The first actor is believed to have been Thespis, which is why actors are sometimes called Thespians.

In India, drama originated from the Natyaveda, and Bharata Muni's Natyashastra became the foundation of Indian theatre. Sanskrit playwrights such as Kalidasa, Bhasa, and Shudraka made significant contributions.

Example: Abhijnanasakuntalam by Kalidasa and Mrichchhakatika by Shudraka are famous Sanskrit plays.


2. Basics of Drama (Othello)


(Figure 2. Basics of Drama: Explained with Othello. Infographic designed with the assistance of ChatGPT (OpenAI), based on William Shakespeare's Othello and standard literary reference sources. Illustration compiled by the researcher.)


Drama tells a story through dialogue, action, and performance. A play is divided into Acts, and each act is further divided into Scenes. Characters express themselves through dialogues, while a soliloquy reveals a character's private thoughts spoken aloud.

Shakespeare's Othello is a five-act tragedy. The protagonist is Othello, while Iago is the antagonist. The handkerchief serves as the central symbol and drives the conflict. The play is mainly set in Venice and Cyprus.

Example: In Othello, Iago manipulates Othello into believing that Desdemona has been unfaithful, leading to a tragic ending.


3. Tragedy



(Figure 3. Tragedy. Infographic designed with the assistance of ChatGPT (OpenAI), based on Aristotle's Poetics, William Shakespeare's tragedies, and standard literary reference sources. Illustration compiled by the researcher.)


A tragedy is a serious play in which the main character suffers because of a tragic flaw (hamartia) or circumstances beyond their control. According to Aristotle's Poetics, tragedy arouses pity and fear, resulting in catharsis, the emotional purification of the audience.

Important concepts include:


Hamartia – tragic flaw

Peripeteia – reversal of fortune

Anagnorisis – recognition of the truth

Catharsis – emotional release


Aristotle identified six elements of tragedy: Plot, Character, Thought, Diction, Music, and Spectacle, with Plot being the most important.

Example: In Othello, Othello's tragic flaw is jealousy, which leads him to kill Desdemona before realizing the truth.


4. William Shakespeare as a Writer


(Figure 4. William Shakespeare as a Writer. Infographic designed with the assistance of ChatGPT (OpenAI), based on William Shakespeare's works and standard literary and historical reference sources. Illustration compiled by the researcher.)


William Shakespeare (1564–1616) is regarded as the greatest playwright in English literature and is popularly known as the Bard of Avon. He lived during the Elizabethan and Jacobean periods and was associated with the Globe Theatre.

He wrote 37 plays, 154 sonnets, and several narrative poems. His plays are generally classified into Tragedies, Comedies, Histories, and Romances. Shakespeare popularized blank verse (unrhymed iambic pentameter) and created memorable characters and universal themes such as love, ambition, jealousy, revenge, and fate.

Examples:


Tragedy: Hamlet, Macbeth, Othello, King Lear


Comedy: Twelfth Night, As You Like It


History: Henry V, Richard III


These four topics provide the foundation for understanding drama as a literary genre, Aristotle's theory of tragedy, Shakespeare's contribution to English literature, and the essential features of Othello.


Take This Quiz to Test Your Learning!

Quiz ( Click on it.) 


Historical Background of Othello




Understanding the historical background helps students appreciate why Shakespeare wrote Othello the way he did. The play is set against a real political and cultural backdrop.


1. Venice and Cyprus

Venice

What was Venice?

Venice was one of the richest and most powerful city-states in Europe during the Renaissance.

It was famous for:

International trade

Naval power

Commerce

Diplomacy

People from different countries, religions, and races visited Venice, making it a cosmopolitan city.

Importance in Othello

Othello serves the Venetian Republic as a respected military general.

Although Venice values Othello's military skill, many people still see him as an outsider because he is a Moor.

This reveals the contrast between public acceptance and private prejudice.

Contemporary Indian Connection

India's major metropolitan cities such as Mumbai, Delhi, and Bengaluru welcome people from different cultures, yet prejudice based on caste, religion, region, or language can still exist.

Cyprus

What was Cyprus?

Cyprus is an island in the eastern Mediterranean Sea.

During Shakespeare's time, it was an important military outpost for Venice.

Whoever controlled Cyprus controlled important sea routes.

Importance in Othello

The action moves from civilized Venice to isolated Cyprus.

In Venice:

Laws operate.

Society is organized.

In Cyprus:

Characters become isolated.

Jealousy and manipulation intensify.

The tragedy unfolds.


Symbolism

Many critics suggest:

Venice = Civilization, law, order

Cyprus = Isolation, war, emotional chaos

Contemporary Example

Think of an army officer transferred from a peaceful headquarters to a remote conflict zone. Isolation and stress can affect judgment and relationships.

2. The Ottoman–Venetian Conflict

Historical Background

During the 15th and 16th centuries:

Venice frequently fought the Ottoman Empire.

Both wanted control of Mediterranean trade routes.

Cyprus became a major point of conflict.

In Othello

At the beginning:

Venice fears an Ottoman attack on Cyprus.

Othello is sent to defend the island.

Ironically:

The Turkish fleet is destroyed by a storm.

The external war ends quickly.

The real conflict becomes internal—jealousy, deception, and revenge.

Symbolism

Shakespeare shifts the focus from:

External war → Internal war

Military enemies → Psychological enemies

The greatest battle is not against the Turks but within Othello's own mind.

Contemporary Example

Sometimes a nation may avoid an external crisis, yet individuals continue to struggle with stress, mistrust, or personal conflicts. Likewise, organizations often survive external competition but are weakened by internal politics.


3. Race and the Concept of the "Moor"

Who was a Moor?

In Shakespeare's England, "Moor" generally referred to people of North African or Muslim origin, often with dark skin. The term was used broadly and did not have one precise meaning.

Othello is presented as:

A distinguished soldier

An outsider

A respected commander

A victim of racial prejudice

Racism in the Play

Although Othello earns respect through his military achievements, characters like Iago and Brabantio use racist language.

Examples include:

"The Moor"

Animal imagery and insults directed at Othello

These remarks show that prejudice exists despite Othello's status.

Shakespeare's Message

Shakespeare demonstrates that:

Ability can overcome many barriers.

Prejudice can still persist.

Society may admire someone's achievements while refusing full acceptance.

Contemporary Indian Example

While India does not have the same racial history as Othello, similar patterns of prejudice can appear through:

Colourism

Caste discrimination

Regional stereotypes

Bias against people from North-East India

Movie Connection

Article 15 (2019) explores discrimination based on caste, helping students understand how social prejudice can affect people's lives even today.


4. Social and Political Setting

Society

The play reflects a patriarchal society where:

Men hold political and military power.

Women are expected to obey fathers and husbands.

Honour and reputation are considered more important than individual freedom.

Politics

Venice is governed by:

The Duke

Senators

Military commanders

Political stability depends on loyal military officers like Othello.

Social Values

People highly value:

Honour

Reputation

Loyalty

Obedience

Masculinity

When these values are questioned, conflicts arise.

Importance in the Play

Almost every tragedy in Othello results from the fear of losing:

Honour

Reputation

Public respect


Contemporary Indian Example


Modern society still places importance on:

Family reputation

Social status

Professional image

Sometimes people make harmful decisions because they fear public shame or social judgment.


Why This Background Matters


Understanding the historical context helps explain why:

Othello is trusted as a general but not fully accepted as a husband.

Cyprus becomes the setting for emotional collapse.

The Ottoman threat gives way to a psychological battle.

Themes of racism, honour, gender, and power continue to resonate in modern societies.


Detailed Character Analysis of Othello by William Shakespeare



1. Othello – The Tragic Hero

Background:

Othello is the protagonist of the play. He is a Moor (a North African Muslim who has converted to Christianity) and serves as the highly respected General of the Venetian army. Despite being an outsider due to his race and foreign origin, he earns admiration through his military brilliance and noble character.

Personality Traits:

Brave and honourable

Intelligent military strategist

Honest and trusting

Passionate in love

Emotionally vulnerable

Insecure about his race and age

Strengths:

Exceptional leadership and courage

Deep love for Desdemona

Strong sense of justice

Commands respect from everyone

Weaknesses (Hamartia):

His tragic flaw is excessive trust. He trusts Iago completely while doubting Desdemona without seeking proof. His jealousy grows because of his insecurity as a racial outsider and an older husband.

Character Development:

Beginning: Calm, dignified, confident, and rational.

Middle: Iago plants doubts regarding Desdemona's fidelity. Othello gradually becomes suspicious and emotionally unstable.

End: Consumed by jealousy, he murders Desdemona. After discovering the truth, he realizes his mistake, feels overwhelming guilt, and commits suicide.

Themes Represented:

Jealousy

Trust and betrayal

Race and identity

Honour

Appearance versus reality

Important Quotes:

"My life upon her faith."

 "O, beware, my lord, of jealousy."

"One that loved not wisely but too well."

Significance:

Othello demonstrates how a noble person can be destroyed not by external enemies but by inner weakness manipulated by evil.

2. Iago – The Villain

Background

Iago is Othello's ensign (flag bearer). He feels insulted because Othello promotes Cassio instead of him.

Personality Traits:

Manipulative

Intelligent

Deceptive

Jealous

Vindictive

Calculating

Motivation:

Several motives are suggested:

Professional jealousy

Personal revenge

Suspicion that Othello had an affair with Emilia

Enjoyment of manipulation itself

Methods:

Lies repeatedly

Manipulates conversations

Uses half-truths

Exploits human weaknesses

Makes others destroy themselves

Character Development:

Unlike Othello, Iago changes very little. He remains consistently evil and manipulative.

Symbolism:

He represents:

Evil

Deception

Hidden malice

Psychological manipulation

Important Quotes:

"I am not what I am."

"Men should be what they seem."

Significance:

Iago is one of Shakespeare's greatest villains because he destroys lives without using physical force. His greatest weapon is language.

3. Desdemona – The Innocent Victim

Background

Desdemona is the daughter of Brabantio. She secretly marries Othello out of genuine love.

Personality Traits:

Loving

Loyal

Compassionate

Honest

Courageous

Independent

Strengths:

Challenges social expectations

Marries for love

Remains faithful

Forgives others easily

Weaknesses:

Excessively trusting

Naïve

Unable to recognize Iago's schemes

Character Development:

She remains constant throughout the play. Even when falsely accused, she continues to love Othello.

Themes Represented:

Innocence

Love

Patriarchal oppression

Female virtue

Important Quotes:

"His unkindness may defeat my life, but never taint my love."

 "A guiltless death I die."

Significance

Desdemona symbolizes purity destroyed by jealousy and patriarchal violence.


4. Michael Cassio – The Honourable Lieutenant

Background

Cassio is promoted to lieutenant instead of Iago.

Personality Traits:

Polite

Educated

Honourable

Respectful

Attractive

Strengths:

Professional competence

Gentlemanly behaviour

Loyalty

Weaknesses

Poor tolerance for alcohol

Concerned with reputation

Character Arc:

Cassio loses his position after a drunken fight engineered by Iago but eventually regains honour and becomes Governor of Cyprus.

Themes:

Reputation

Honour

Manipulation

Important Quote:

"Reputation, reputation, reputation!"

5. Emilia – The Voice of Truth

Background

Emilia is Iago's wife and Desdemona's attendant.

Personality Traits:

Practical

Honest

Courageous

Intelligent

Outspoken

Character Development:

Initially obedient to Iago, she later realizes his wickedness. She courageously exposes him despite knowing the danger, sacrificing her own life.

Symbolism:

She represents:

Truth

Female courage

Moral awakening

Important Quote:

 "They are all but stomachs, and we all but food."

Significance:

Emilia is the moral centre of the final act.

6. Roderigo – The Foolish Lover

Background

A wealthy Venetian gentleman who loves Desdemona.

Personality Traits:

Naïve

Wealthy

Easily manipulated

Emotional

Role:

Iago repeatedly exploits him for money and persuades him to commit crimes.

Significance:

He illustrates how blind love makes people vulnerable to manipulation.

7. Brabantio – Desdemona's Father

Background

A respected Venetian senator.

Personality Traits:

Proud

Protective

Racist

Authoritative

Importance:

He cannot accept Desdemona's marriage to Othello and believes she was bewitched.

Important Quote:

"She has deceived her father, and may thee."

Ironically, Iago later uses this statement to increase Othello's suspicion.

8. Bianca

Background

A courtesan deeply attached to Cassio.

Personality Traits:

Loving

Emotional

Honest

Significance:

Although society looks down upon her, Bianca proves more faithful than many respectable characters, highlighting Shakespeare's criticism of social prejudice.

9. Duke of Venice

Personality Traits:

Wise

Diplomatic

Fair-minded

Importance:

He values Othello for his military service and approves the marriage after hearing both sides.

10. Lodovico

Background

A nobleman from Venice and Desdemona's cousin.

Importance:

He witnesses Othello's transformation and later helps restore justice by exposing Iago's crimes.

11. Montano

Background

Former Governor of Cyprus.

Importance:

His injury during Cassio's drunken fight leads to Cassio's dismissal, advancing Iago's plan.

12. Gratiano

Background

Brother of Brabantio.

Importance

He confirms Brabantio's death and assists in restoring order at the end of the play.

Relationships Between Major Characters

Character Relationship Significance

Othello – Desdemona Husband and wife Love destroyed by jealousy

Othello – Iago General and ensign Trust exploited through deception

Iago – Emilia Husband and wife Abuse and betrayal

Cassio – Desdemona Friends Misinterpreted as an affair

Iago – Roderigo Manipulator and victim Exploitation for personal gain

Brabantio – Desdemona Father and daughter Conflict between authority and personal choice


Character Map


IAGO

             / | \

            / | \

      OTHELLO CASSIO RODERIGO

          | |

          | |

     DESDEMONA----|

          |

       EMILIA


Major Character Functions


Character Dramatic Function


Othello Tragic Hero

Iago Villain/Antagonist

Desdemona Innocent Heroine

Cassio Loyal Lieutenant

Emilia Truth Revealer

Roderigo Comic/Foolish Victim

Brabantio Patriarchal Authority

Bianca Social Outsider

Duke Justice and Political Authority


Examination Points 


Othello embodies the Aristotelian tragic hero whose downfall results from jealousy and misplaced trust.


Iago is Shakespeare's most accomplished Machiavellian villain, manipulating others through deception and psychological insight.


Desdemona represents unwavering love, innocence, and moral integrity.


Emilia evolves into the play's moral conscience by exposing Iago's crimes.


Cassio symbolizes honour and reputation.


Roderigo demonstrates the dangers of obsession and gullibility.


Brabantio reflects racial prejudice and patriarchal values.


Together, these characters reinforce the play's central themes of jealousy, appearance versus reality, trust, betrayal, race, gender, and the tragic consequences of manipulation.



Major Themes 




Othello is not just a tragedy of a jealous husband; it explores universal human emotions and social issues that remain relevant today. Below are the major themes with textual examples and contemporary relevance.


1. Jealousy – The "Green-Eyed Monster"

Definition: Jealousy is the central theme of Othello. Shakespeare portrays it as a destructive emotion capable of ruining even noble individuals.

In the Play:

Iago becomes jealous because Othello promotes Cassio instead of him.

He manipulates Othello into believing that Desdemona is unfaithful.

Othello's irrational jealousy transforms him from a respected general into a murderer.

Example:

"O, beware, my lord, of jealousy; it is the green-eyed monster." (Act 3, Scene 3)

Ironically, Iago himself creates the very monster he warns against.

Contemporary Example:

A person constantly checks their partner's phone and social media due to insecurity.

False rumours on social media destroy relationships and marriages.

Examination Point: Shakespeare presents jealousy as self-destructive rather than evidence-based.


2. Appearance vs Reality

Definition: Things are rarely what they appear to be.

In the Play:

Iago pretends to be honest while secretly plotting evil.

Cassio appears guilty although he is innocent.

Desdemona appears unfaithful only because of Iago's deception.

Example:

 "I am not what I am." (Act 1, Scene 1)

This statement summarizes Iago's deceptive nature.

Contemporary Example:

Fake social media identities.

Online scams where criminals pretend to be trustworthy.

Examination Point: The tragedy occurs because Othello believes appearances instead of seeking truth.


3. Deception and Manipulation

Definition: The deliberate control of others through lies.

In the Play:

Iago manipulates Roderigo, Cassio, Othello, and even Emilia.

The handkerchief becomes false evidence.

Every major event results from manipulation.

Example: Iago carefully plants suspicion without directly accusing Desdemona.

Contemporary Example:

Fake news influencing public opinion.

Emotional manipulation in toxic relationships.

Corporate politics and workplace conspiracies.

Examination Point: Words can become weapons more dangerous than swords.


4. Racism and Otherness

Definition: Prejudice based on race or ethnicity.

In the Play:

Othello is respected as a soldier but rejected socially because he is a Moor.

Brabantio insults Othello because of his race.

Iago repeatedly uses racist language.

Examples:

"The Moor"

"An old black ram is tupping your white ewe."

These expressions reveal racial prejudice.

Contemporary Example:

Racial discrimination.

Colourism.

Xenophobia against immigrants.

Examination Point: Othello's outsider status makes him vulnerable to insecurity and manipulation.


5. Love and Trust

Definition: Love requires mutual trust.

In the Play:

Othello and Desdemona genuinely love each other.

Their relationship collapses because trust is replaced by suspicion.

Example: Othello trusts Iago more than Desdemona.

Contemporary Example:

Marriages breaking due to misunderstandings.

Relationships damaged by misinformation.

Examination Point: Without trust, love cannot survive.


6. Gender and Patriarchy

Definition: Women's roles and male dominance in society.

In the Play:

Desdemona is expected to obey her husband.

Emilia criticizes men's treatment of women.

Bianca is judged because of her social status.

Example: Emilia argues that women have the same emotions as men.

Contemporary Example:

Gender inequality.

Domestic violence.

Workplace discrimination against women.

Examination Point: Emilia becomes Shakespeare's voice for gender equality.


7. Revenge

Definition: Seeking personal justice through retaliation.

In the Play:

Iago seeks revenge for being passed over for promotion.

He also suspects Othello had an affair with Emilia.

His revenge destroys innocent lives.

Contemporary Example:

Workplace revenge.

Cyberbullying.

Revenge pornography.

Examination Point: Revenge ultimately destroys both the victim and the avenger.


8. Honour and Reputation

Definition: A person's social respect and dignity.

In the Play:

Cassio values his reputation above everything.

Othello believes Desdemona has destroyed his honour.

Iago exploits everyone's concern for reputation.

Example: Cassio laments:

"Reputation, reputation, reputation!"

Contemporary Example:

Character assassination on social media.

Online defamation.

Public cancellation.

Examination Point: Characters often value reputation more than truth.


9. Good vs Evil

Definition: The conflict between morality and wickedness.

In the Play:

Desdemona represents innocence.

Emilia ultimately chooses truth.

Iago represents calculated evil.

Contemporary Example:

Corrupt leaders versus ethical whistle-blowers.

Fraud versus integrity.

Examination Point: Evil succeeds temporarily because good people trust too easily.


10. Power and Ambition

Definition: The desire for authority and status.

In the Play:

Iago wants military promotion.

Othello holds political and military power.

Cassio's promotion becomes the root of conflict.

Contemporary Example:

Office politics.

Political rivalries.

Corporate competition.

Examination Point: Unchecked ambition leads to betrayal.


11. Fate vs Free Will

Definition: Are people controlled by destiny or by their own choices?

In the Play:

Iago influences events, but Othello chooses to believe him.

Othello freely decides to kill Desdemona.

Contemporary Example:

Blaming fate instead of accepting responsibility.

Making impulsive decisions based on rumours.

Examination Point: Shakespeare suggests that human choices, not fate alone, create tragedy.


12. Innocence and Guilt

Definition: The contrast between the innocent and the guilty.

In the Play:

Desdemona is completely innocent.

Emilia is initially unaware of Iago's plans but later exposes him.

Iago is guilty but refuses to confess.

Contemporary Example:

Wrongful accusations.

Innocent people suffering because of false allegations.

Examination Point: Truth often emerges too late to save the innocent.


13. Reason vs Passion

Definition: The struggle between rational thinking and overpowering emotion.

In the Play:

Othello begins as a calm and rational leader.

Under Iago's influence, he abandons reason and acts out of passion and jealousy.

Contemporary Example:

Making life-changing decisions in anger.

Reacting to viral misinformation without verifying facts.

Examination Point: When passion overcomes reason, tragedy follows.


14. Communication and Miscommunication

Definition: Failures in honest communication can create conflict.

In the Play:

Othello never openly asks Desdemona about the accusations.

The missing handkerchief is misunderstood.

Honest conversations are replaced by assumptions.

Contemporary Example:

Relationships ending because of unanswered messages or misunderstood texts.

Conflicts caused by rumours rather than direct communication.

Examination Point: Many tragedies in Othello could have been avoided through open and truthful communication.


Conclusion 

Shakespeare's Othello explores timeless themes such as jealousy, deception, racism, love, trust, revenge, honour, gender inequality, appearance versus reality, power, free will, communication, and the conflict between reason and passion. These themes remain deeply relevant in the modern world, where misinformation, prejudice, toxic relationships, workplace rivalry, and social media continue to influence human behaviour. The enduring relevance of these themes is one of the reasons Othello remains one of Shakespeare's greatest tragedies and a significant text in English literature.


In Othello, Shakespeare uses several important symbols to represent themes such as love, jealousy, deception, race, and honor.


1. The Handkerchief

Meaning:

The most important symbol in the play.

Represents Othello and Desdemona's love and fidelity.

When it is lost and found by Cassio, it becomes "evidence" of Desdemona's supposed infidelity.

Symbolizes how a small object can be manipulated into a tool of deception.

Theme: Love, trust, jealousy, betrayal.


2. The Willow Song

Meaning:

Desdemona sings the "Willow Song" before her death.

Traditionally associated with abandoned or unhappy women.

Foreshadows Desdemona's tragic fate.

Theme: Sorrow, innocence, fate.


3. The Wedding Bed

Meaning:

Symbolizes the couple's love and marital union.

Ironically becomes the place where Othello murders Desdemona.

Shows the destruction of love by jealousy.

Theme: Love, death, tragedy.


4. Light and Darkness

Meaning:

Light often symbolizes truth, innocence, and goodness.

Darkness symbolizes jealousy, ignorance, and evil intentions.


Othello extinguishes a candle before killing Desdemona, symbolizing the extinguishing of her life.


Theme: Truth vs. deception, innocence vs. evil.


5. Animal Imagery

Meaning:

Iago frequently uses animal images ("old black ram," "beast with two backs").

These images dehumanize Othello and reduce love to lust.

Reflect prejudice and Iago's malicious nature.

Theme: Racism, prejudice, manipulation.


6. The Sea and the Storm

Meaning:

The storm that destroys the Turkish fleet symbolizes chaos and conflict.

Mirrors the emotional storm that later develops in Othello's mind.

Theme: Disorder, emotional turmoil, fate.


 (Short Answer)

Major symbols in Othello:


1. The Handkerchief – love, fidelity, jealousy.


2. The Willow Song – sorrow and impending death.


3. The Wedding Bed – love transformed into tragedy.


4. Light and Darkness – truth versus deception.


5. Animal Imagery – racism and degradation.


6. The Sea/Storm – emotional and social chaos.


The handkerchief is generally considered the central symbol of the play because it drives the tragic action and embodies the themes of love, trust, and jealousy.


Critical Perspectives

Aristotelian tragedy

Tragic hero

Hamartia

Catharsis

Feminist criticism

Psychoanalytic reading

Marxist reading

Postcolonial reading

New Historicist reading


Othello in the Contemporary Indian Context


1. Fake News and Misinformation

Meaning: False or misleading information spread to deceive others.

In Othello:

Iago convinces Othello that Desdemona is unfaithful.

He plants the handkerchief as false evidence.

Othello believes rumours instead of verifying the truth.

Example from the play:

"Look to your wife; observe her well with Cassio."

Indian Example:

False WhatsApp forwards have triggered panic, damaged reputations, and even led to mob violence in some parts of India.

Rumours spread rapidly on social media during elections or communal tensions, influencing public opinion before facts are verified.

Movie Example: Drishyam (2015) demonstrates how carefully constructed false narratives can manipulate people's understanding of events, highlighting the power of information and misinformation.

Teaching Point: Always verify facts before believing or sharing information.

2. Gaslighting and Psychological Manipulation

Meaning: Manipulating someone into doubting their own judgment or sanity.

In Othello:

Iago never directly accuses Desdemona.

Instead, he plants suspicion in Othello's mind.

Othello gradually loses trust in his own reasoning.

Example:

"O, beware, my lord, of jealousy."

Indian Example:

Emotional manipulation in relationships where one partner constantly says:

"You're overthinking."

"You're imagining things."

"Nobody will believe you."

Movie Example: Thappad (2020) explores emotional control and manipulation within a marriage, showing how subtle forms of abuse can become normalized.

Teaching Point: Manipulation often appears as advice or concern.

3. Toxic Relationships

Meaning: Relationships based on control, mistrust, fear, or emotional abuse.

In Othello:

Love gradually turns into suspicion.

Othello refuses honest communication.

Jealousy destroys the marriage.

Indian Example:

Excessive monitoring of a partner's phone.

Restricting friendships.

Constant suspicion without evidence.

Movie Example: Kabir Singh (2019) has been widely discussed for portraying possessiveness, controlling behaviour, and unhealthy relationship dynamics. While some viewers see it as romance, others criticize it as depicting toxic behaviour.

Teaching Point: Love without trust becomes destructive.

4. Workplace Politics

Meaning: Rivalry, favouritism, jealousy, and manipulation at work.

In Othello:

Cassio receives the promotion.

Iago feels overlooked.

Instead of improving himself, he plots revenge.

Example:

"I know my price."

Indian Example:

Office gossip to undermine colleagues.

Jealousy over promotions.

Credit for work being taken by others.

Movie Example: Rocket Singh: Salesman of the Year (2009) explores office politics, unethical competition, and integrity in the corporate world.

Teaching Point: Merit should prevail over manipulation.

5. Racial Prejudice

Meaning: Discrimination based on race or ethnicity.

In Othello:

Othello is repeatedly called insulting names because he is a Moor.

His marriage is judged partly because of his racial identity.

Indian Example:

Discrimination against people from North-East India.

Colourism, where lighter skin is often unfairly associated with beauty or status.

Bias based on caste, region, or language can function similarly by treating some groups as "outsiders."

Movie Example: Article 15 (2019) examines caste-based discrimination, showing how prejudice and exclusion can shape people's lives.

Teaching Point: Judge people by their character and actions, not by identity.

6. Honour-Based Violence

Meaning: Violence committed in the name of protecting family or personal honour.

In Othello:

Othello believes Desdemona has dishonoured him.

He kills her believing he is restoring his honour.

Indian Example:

Honour killings involving couples who marry against family wishes.

Violence or threats over inter-caste or inter-faith marriages.

Movie Example: Sairat (Marathi, 2016) powerfully portrays honour-based violence resulting from caste prejudice. Its Hindi adaptation, Dhadak (2018), explores similar themes.

Teaching Point: Honour can never justify violence.

7. Domestic Abuse

Meaning: Physical, emotional, verbal, or psychological abuse within intimate relationships.

In Othello:

Othello publicly humiliates Desdemona.

He eventually murders her.

Emilia also suffers emotional abuse from Iago.

Indian Example:

Domestic violence remains a significant social issue.

Emotional abuse, coercive control, and economic dependence are forms of abuse alongside physical violence.

Movie Example: Thappad (2020) shows how even a single act of violence can expose deeper patterns of inequality and disrespect within a marriage.

Teaching Point: Abuse often begins with control and emotional manipulation before escalating.

8. Gender Stereotypes

Meaning: Fixed beliefs about how men and women should behave.

In Othello:

Women are expected to be obedient.

Desdemona is criticised for choosing her own husband.

Emilia challenges patriarchal assumptions.

Example: Emilia argues that women have the same emotions and desires as men.

Indian Example:

Pressure on women to prioritise family over careers.

The belief that men should not express vulnerability or emotions.

Movie Example: Pink (2016) challenges stereotypes about women's autonomy and consent, questioning how society judges women's choices.

Teaching Point: Shakespeare not only reflects patriarchal values but also questions them through characters like Emilia.


Classroom Discussion Question

"If Othello lived in 21st-century India with mobile phones, CCTV, call records, and social media, could Iago still have succeeded? Why or why not?"


Practice Questions 

Discuss Othello as a Tragic Hero, Highlighting His Nobility, Flaws, and Their Role in His Downfall.

Introduction

William Shakespeare, the greatest dramatist of the English Renaissance, produced some of the finest tragedies in world literature, including Hamlet, Macbeth, King Lear, and Othello. Written around 1604, Othello is a powerful tragedy that explores love, jealousy, deception, and human weakness. Aristotle defines a tragic hero as a person of high rank whose downfall results from a fatal flaw (hamartia), leading to peripeteia (reversal of fortune), anagnorisis (recognition), and ultimately catharsis (pity and fear) in the audience. Othello fulfills all these characteristics and is therefore regarded as one of Shakespeare's greatest tragic heroes.

Othello's Nobility and Greatness

At the beginning of the play, Othello is presented as a noble, courageous, and respected general in the service of Venice. He has risen to a position of honour through merit, bravery, and military excellence. The Duke trusts him completely, and even his enemies acknowledge his worth. His speech is dignified, controlled, and full of confidence. Desdemona falls in love with him because of his character and heroic experiences rather than his appearance or social status.

Desdemona declares:

“I saw Othello's visage in his mind.”

This statement emphasizes Othello's inner nobility. He is honest, loyal, and deeply devoted to his wife. A. C. Bradley describes Othello as an exceptionally noble and trustful man whose greatness makes his fall profoundly moving.

Othello's Hamartia: The Fatal Flaw

Like every tragic hero, Othello possesses a fatal flaw. His tragedy arises from excessive trust, emotional impulsiveness, and a susceptibility to jealousy. Importantly, Othello is not naturally jealous. As Bradley points out, he is “not easily jealous,” but once his trust is shaken, he becomes “perplexed in the extreme.”

Iago skillfully exploits Othello's trusting nature and gradually poisons his mind with suspicion. Instead of seeking proof from Desdemona, Othello places complete faith in Iago, repeatedly calling him “honest Iago.” The handkerchief becomes false “ocular proof” and convinces Othello that Desdemona has betrayed him.

His flaw is therefore not simple jealousy but the combination of blind trust, insecurity, and uncontrolled passion. Once jealousy takes hold, reason loses its power over him. As Iago warns:

“O, beware, my lord, of jealousy;

It is the green-eyed monster.”

Ironically, Othello becomes the very victim of this destructive emotion.

Iago's Manipulation and Othello's Peripeteia

The tragedy develops through the interaction between Othello's weakness and Iago's evil intelligence. Iago functions as the external force that exploits Othello's internal flaw. Through lies, insinuations, and fabricated evidence, he gradually destroys Othello's confidence in Desdemona.

The turning point (peripeteia) occurs when Othello transforms from a loving husband into a jealous avenger. The noble general who once valued justice and reason becomes consumed by suspicion and rage. Shakespeare demonstrates that evil succeeds only when it finds a weakness within the individual. Thus, Othello's downfall is caused not only by Iago's villainy but also by his own failure to balance emotion with reason. Bradley rightly observes that Iago's plot succeeds because it is perfectly adapted to Othello's character.

Anagnorisis and the Tragic Downfall

The climax of the tragedy occurs when Othello murders Desdemona, believing that he is protecting honour and justice. Soon afterward, Emilia exposes Iago's deception, and Othello realizes the terrible truth. This moment of self-discovery is Aristotle's anagnorisis or tragic recognition.

Overwhelmed by guilt and remorse, Othello understands that he has destroyed the innocent woman he loved most. His final speech reveals both self-awareness and suffering:

“Of one that loved not wisely but too well.”

Recognizing the enormity of his mistake, he punishes himself by committing suicide. His death completes the tragic pattern of a great man brought low by an error of judgment. The audience experiences catharsis through feelings of pity for Othello and fear at the destructive power of jealousy.

Critical Evaluation

Othello is one of Shakespeare's most complex tragic heroes because his downfall emerges from both his greatness and his weakness. He is neither a villain nor a fool. Rather, he is a noble man whose virtues become vulnerable to manipulation. Bradley argues that Othello's trust is absolute and that, once convinced, he acts with irresistible force. His tragedy lies in the collapse of faith, love, and reason under the influence of jealousy.

Unlike Macbeth, whose downfall results from ambition, or King Lear, whose tragedy arises from pride, Othello is destroyed by misplaced trust and emotional excess. His fall from a respected general to a remorseful murderer illustrates Aristotle's principle that a great person is ruined not by wickedness but by a tragic error of judgment.

Conclusion

To conclude, Othello perfectly embodies the characteristics of an Aristotelian tragic hero. He is noble, courageous, and admired, yet possesses fatal flaws that lead to his destruction. His excessive trust in Iago, growing jealousy, and impulsive nature result in a catastrophic error that destroys both Desdemona and himself. Through hamartia, peripeteia, anagnorisis, and catharsis, Shakespeare presents the tragic fall of a great man. Therefore, Othello remains one of the most memorable and powerful tragic heroes in English literature, evoking sympathy, admiration, and profound tragic insight in readers and audiences alike.


Write a Note on the Character of Desdemona.


Introduction


Desdemona is one of the most important and admirable characters in William Shakespeare's Othello. As the daughter of Brabantio and the wife of Othello, she plays a central role in the development of the tragedy. Shakespeare presents her as a woman of beauty, innocence, courage, loyalty, and unwavering love. Although she becomes a victim of jealousy and deception, her goodness and moral strength remain unchanged throughout the play. Desdemona represents purity and virtue, making her one of Shakespeare's most memorable heroines.

Desdemona as a Loving and Devoted Wife

One of Desdemona's most striking qualities is her deep love for Othello. She chooses Othello as her husband despite differences of race, age, and social expectations. Her love is based on admiration for his character and experiences rather than outward appearance. She openly declares her commitment to him before the Duke and the Senate, showing remarkable courage and sincerity.

Desdemona's devotion remains constant even when Othello begins to mistreat her. She never stops loving him and continues to care for him despite his harsh behaviour. Her loyalty demonstrates the depth of her affection and commitment.

Desdemona's Courage and Independence

Although Desdemona appears gentle and obedient, she is also courageous and independent. In a society where women were expected to obey their fathers, she boldly chooses her own husband. She defends her decision before the Venetian authorities and insists on accompanying Othello to Cyprus.

Her famous statement,

“I do perceive here a divided duty,”

reveals her maturity and determination. By marrying Othello against her father's wishes, she challenges social conventions and exercises her freedom of choice. Thus, Desdemona is not merely passive but a woman capable of making independent decisions.

Desdemona's Innocence and Purity

Desdemona is the moral centre of the play. She is innocent, honest, and free from deceit. Unlike Iago, who represents evil and manipulation, Desdemona symbolizes goodness and truth. Her concern for Cassio arises from kindness and friendship, yet Othello misinterprets her actions as evidence of infidelity.

Throughout the play, she remains faithful to her husband. Even when falsely accused, she refuses to speak ill of Othello. Her purity is highlighted by the contrast between her character and the corruption surrounding her.

Desdemona as a Tragic Victim

Desdemona becomes the tragic victim of Iago's scheme and Othello's jealousy. Despite her innocence, she suffers humiliation, rejection, and ultimately death. Her tragedy lies in the fact that she is punished for a crime she never committed.

In the final scene, even as she faces death, she continues to protect Othello. Her last words reveal forgiveness rather than anger. This extraordinary compassion enhances her tragic stature and evokes deep sympathy from the audience.

Desdemona's Role in the Tragedy

Desdemona's character contributes significantly to the emotional impact of Othello. Her innocence intensifies the audience's hatred of Iago and increases the sense of tragedy when Othello kills her. Shakespeare uses her character to explore themes of love, trust, jealousy, and the vulnerability of goodness in a world corrupted by evil.

Critics often regard Desdemona as the embodiment of love and virtue. A. C. Bradley describes her as one of Shakespeare's sweetest and most appealing heroines. Her moral strength and unwavering loyalty make her an unforgettable character.

Conclusion

To conclude, Desdemona is a noble, loving, courageous, and virtuous woman whose character forms the emotional heart of Othello. Her unwavering love for Othello, her innocence, and her moral integrity make her one of Shakespeare's finest female characters. Although she becomes the victim of jealousy and deception, she remains faithful to her values until the end. Through Desdemona, Shakespeare celebrates the ideals of love, loyalty, and goodness while highlighting the tragic consequences of mistrust and jealousy.


Works Cited 

Aristotle. Poetics. Translated by Malcolm Heath, Penguin Classics, 1996.

Baldick, Chris. The Oxford Dictionary of Literary Terms. 4th ed., Oxford University Press, 2015.

Brockett, Oscar G., and Franklin J. Hildy. History of the Theatre. 11th ed., Pearson, 2014.

Shakespeare, William. Othello. Edited by E. A. J. Honigmann, Arden Shakespeare, 3rd ed., Bloomsbury, 2016.

Wells, Stanley, and Gary Taylor, editors. The Complete Works of William Shakespeare. 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, 2005.


Thursday, 4 January 2024

Human Interest: A Service of Love by O Henry

 


O. Henry was the pen name of William Sydney Porter, an American short story writer born on September 11, 1862, and who passed away on June 5, 1910. He is renowned for his wit, wordplay, and clever twist endings in his short stories. O. Henry's stories often feature ordinary people in everyday situations, and he was known for his ability to capture the essence of life in New York City during the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Some of his well-known works include "The Gift of the Magi," "The Ransom of Red Chief," and, as mentioned earlier, "A Service of Love." His writing style is characterized by a combination of humor, irony, and sympathy for his characters. O. Henry's stories have enduring popularity due to their engaging plots and surprise endings, making him a significant figure in American literature.

A Service of Love" by O. Henry is a short story that explores themes of sacrifice and unexpected twists in relationships. The story revolves around Delia Caruthers and Joe Larrabee, where Delia, a struggling artist and singer, falls in love with Joe, a painter. Both get married and start living together. Joe is unaware of Delia's feelings. Delia, determined to help Joe, takes on the duty of a private tutor and provides music lessons to Celementina, a daughter of General A. B. Pinkney. Joe, in turn, is also trying to earn money by selling paintings.

The story takes an unexpected turn when each person sacrifices their most prized possession, their hobbies, to provide happiness for each other. Their acts of love are poignant, showcasing the theme of selflessness. O. Henry's signature twist ending is revealed when they come to know about their hidden work profession as they both work in laundry, leading to a bittersweet conclusion.

 

Overall, "A Service of Love" is a tale that highlights the complexities of love, sacrifice, and the unpredictability of life. O. Henry's storytelling skill is evident in the way he weaves together the characters' lives and emotions, leaving readers with a memorable and thought-provoking narrative.



Task : 

1. Discuss how O Henry employs the theme of sacrifice and love throughout the story 'A Service of Love'.

2. What is the significance of the title of the story? Discuss.

3. What title would you choose if you were asked to do so? 

4. Translate the song "Monta Re" into English without the help of Google Sources and then cross-check. (Lootera is a Bollywood movie adapted from the short story Last Leaf by O. Henry.) Upload the translation photo to your blog.



Thursday, 4 February 2021

Since There's No Help By Michael Drayton

 


         The sonnet( 61) 'Since There's No Help' is written by Michael Drayton.  (Click On It ) Who is considered as one of the famous poet of Elizabethan Age after Shakespeare and Sidney. That can be seen in the structure of this sonnet as it follows the format of Shakespearean sonnet. This sonnet is the part of the book named Idea's  Mirrors. Which was published in 1594. Here we shall see the general meaning of the poem.  

          The whole poem is centred around the theme of lovers' separation. Which can be seen in the title too. While reading the sonnet, we come across such words which follows the first person narrative techniques. Here one thing gets clear that it is the feeling of author/ narrator for his beloved.  

Since there's no help, come let us kiss and part; 

  Nay, I have done, you get no more of me, 

 And I am glad, yea, glad with all my heart, 

    That thus so cleanly I myself can free; 



        In the very first quatrain poet says to his beloved that 'let's us kiss and part.' It means something has already happened in the past, which we don't know. What we know is that narrator and his beloved both are ready to depart. May be their future is not together. The lover shares his thought regarding his relationship with her. In addition, he is now glad to depart as that will make both of them free from everything. But the tone is full of melancholy. 

  Shake hands for ever, cancel all our vows, 
      And when we meet any time again, 
      Be it not seen in either of our brows
    That we one jot of former love retain.  


     However,  the next quatrain has some hope.  Or we can say there's some indirect communication between them which only they can understand. Now, the narrator is ready to shake hands for the last time, probably before escorting her. Who tells his beloved to cancel all past vows.  It means, lovers know that how past memories can affect them.  So it is better to forget everything. Suddenly, there's certain change in tone as writer shows some hope for the future encounter. Again the lover tells his beloved that if they meet in future life, they will pretend as strangers. And for that he provides the reason also. Because, that can help them to reinvent their love for each other.  

Now at the last gasp of love's latest breath, 
When, his pulse failing, passion speechless lies, 
When faith is kneeling by his bed of death, 
And innocence is closing up his eyes,

Now if thou ( You) wouldst, when all have given him over, 
From death to life thou mightst him yet recover.  


    The next stanza sounds more seducing.  But with wooing intent. The lover tells his beloved that the love is almost dead now. There's no more passion.  And he regrets that there's no trust, faith anymore in this relationship. Or we can say that their relationship is without soul now. As we have reached at the concluding part of the poem, similarly, the lover expresses his final words by telling his beloved that the retrieval of this relationship is in the hands of his beloved. Which makes his stand clear.  

     In conclusion we can say that the end of the poem is some how optimistic as the beloved doesn't answer anything. Which makes narrator hopeful to revive his love.  

Rhyming Scheme : ABAB CDCD EFEF GG 
Personifications : "Faith" is kneeling... 
                                 "Innocence" is closing... 

Further Readings : 




           




        






Thursday, 20 December 2018

Short Stories by Vishal Bhadani

         In 21st century the literary genre of Short Story holds the attention of audience. In general, short story is a fictional prose,  which has self contained event with the help of fiction. As we all know that in this hustle and bustle of life people have not enough  time to read bulky books, but one can read short story in single sitting, which has literary elements and effects like exposition, climax and resolution. 
           Moreover, in current time these short stories have not traditional ending. These short stories are open ended, which makes this form more interesting. 
           Here I would like to share my interpretation of the short stories written by Vishal Bhadani. 



1-  " Mara Hathni Vaat Nathi "

• Significant Title : 
    This story has an interesting title. Because whole story moves around the word ' hath'. Here we can see how writer tries to play with the word. For example...
- Hath : Hand, An organ of the body 
- Hath ni vaat nathi : Incapable Of doing something 
           But what we find is that narrator is able to give justice to his work. 

• Subject : 
        The subject of the story is also minutely observed. What we think is that we never think about a hand, or rather the work of hand. According to us it is like a trivial things to think about the process of a hand. But here writer turns these simple process into 'golden arm'. 
        There are many modernist writer who has used these kinds of subject in their works. For example, the character of Estragon trying to take off his boot in the play 'Waiting for Godot' by Samuel Beckett. 
         Altogether what we find is the literary skills of writer. Almost all the words has a deep meaning in it. 

• Symbolism by the different parts of hand :
- નખ 
- ટેરવા 
- કાંડુ
- હથેળી 
- ખોબો 
- કોણી 
- ખભો 
- આંગળીઓ 
- અંગૂઠો 

• Representation of current situation :
     As the main aim of literature is not to merely entertain the audience but to unfold the pitfalls of society. And that thing we can see in this story. 

Let us go word by word : 
  
~ " ઉફાળો દિશા બદલી નાખે અેવું મને ઘણીવાર થાય છે ."
By reading this sentence what we get is, over excitement is not good. There are such kinds of impulse which may leads towards the fall. The best example of it, is the current situation of BJP. 

~ Nail  : Most of the time we never think about nail. But how dangerous it is,  that we can get by reading the play, 'The Birthday Party' by Harold Pinter.  How scratching of the nail becomes irritating and weird, so again this trivial things becomes more serious.

~ Wrist and Syria : Here we can interpret that because of the Syrian civil war many peoples are dying.  By going with traditional sense Syrian women are becoming widows, and as a result of it they are not able to wear ornaments.

~ ' Ram Mandir' :  Yes, well needed satire.  In contemporary time we see that people have no time to think on basic problems of nation. But if the issue is of religion then suddenly they all will rush to the bandwagon. People are yet not learning from the history. e.g. Jerusalem Issues

~ ' Tilak' / Tikka : When we hear the word 'Tilak', then suddenly we recall the 'Akho'. So the questions arises in our mind  is that why people do tikka on their foreheads...? Does it increases beauty? Or because of scientific reason...? Or is it for mere boasting ... ?

~ પ્રેમ વિશે કેમ લખાય ?
As we all know that literature should be universal. All human beings have a right of freedom of expression. But these so called bureaucrats and custodians are like a frog in the Well. They considers this 'Prem ' as  a western ghost. But they have not read the history properly. e. g. : Kama Sutra by Vatsyayana, Kama & Rati, Shakuntala & Dushyant,  Menaka & Vishwamitra, etc. What we find is that we are becoming more narrower. And as a repercussion of it we have lost so many writers and journalists.

~ Binaries : If there is no #other then there is no superiority complex. But here narrator has shown the binaries which prevails during rituals. Like one can not use left hand in the rituals, but reality is that either you use right hand or left hand nothing happens. The another great example is of palmistry. Here narrator satires on astrology. Because if by accident person might loose the palm lines, so it doesn't mean person will not get success.



~ Gun and Riots :  It reminds us about the Gujarat riots. This reference is direct satire on the people. Because people are supposed to be intellectual but they are becoming violent and sheeple.

~ ' મેં જેવી પેન ઉપાડી કે આંગળીઓ હડતાળ પર ચાલી ગઈ.'
In India most of the time we find people on strikes. But this idea is indirectly supports the faineant. It looks more regressive. In a way it affects the progress of nation. Yes, one should protest against the power but this method more suits to them. As a solution of it people should insist to keep all the offices open for 24/7. This idea of strike will not protect us from the menace of scrimshanker.

           Eventually here we can say that writer has shown the great skills of literature. Because here you have to give effect of an ocean in the form of lake. An interesting thing is that narrator seems pessoptimist. As he has portrayed so many things related to a hand, but yet at the end he tells that ....."હાથ વિશે વાત કરવી એ મારા હાથની વાત નથી."

2 - ' Spring ' 

         What a work of fiction ! (It may have real life event) When we read the title of the story suddenly so many thoughts starts running in our mind. As there are so many meanings of the word 'Spring'.
      It is the title which makes us more curious to read the story. Like is it refers to season or to an elastic device...? But what we get in the story is totally different.

Narrative Technique :

        All stories have different narratives. But yes,  it is it's narration which makes this story more interesting. It looks like Frame Narratives or we can say story within story. As in the story, after arranging the stage, Protagonist (Dharamshi) himself narrates the story. Within this narration protagonist subconsciously reveals his past. Here Dharamshi thinks that whatever he has done in the past that his friends and relatives came to know by watching ( In waiting room display)  this balloon angioplasty (Stent in heart) or spring retractor. But they knows nothing.

Creative writing : 

         This story shows us creative insight of writer. Here a tool becomes the reason of person's confession. Which reminds us robotic (Scientific) achievements. And also the menace of it. e. g. :  Bollywood movie Robot and 'Frankenstein' by Mary Shelley. 

Conscience / Confession / Mystery :

        After reading the story what we find is that ' Dharamshi ' subconsciously  describes his past events. Like his visit of maternal home, where he secretly peeps somewhere,  stealing, fighting between him and his brother, betrayal to his friend Mulji, his secret meeting with lover 'Ajwali', etc.
        Altogether 'conscience ' becomes more powerful over person and  starts revealing his crimes as same as Poe's characters (Protagonist) does in his mysterious short stories.
         Another interesting element of this story is ' confession'. Because without confession of the past, life becomes difficult for the protagonist and as a result of it he suffers from heart attack. Which reminds us about the character of Arthur Dimmesdale. 


          At the end of the story again we stuck in  the meaning of the word spring. Because for a while it seems story is about a stent in the heart,or about deep desire for homeland but suddenly it seems that his conscience springs and as a result of it life becomes difficult for him.

3 - ' સાંસાઈ અને રમજાના ' :

          Another great piece of work. The title of the story makes us more imaginative. In the beginning we just get confused about the characters. And that's the complexity ! It looks like flashback narratives.

• Blanks : 
          Writer has used the unique technique of leaving blanks in the story. Which provides an opportunity to the readers to think on their own.

•     We have seen the behavior of person, and the minute process of hand in his previous stories. Now writers takes us near to the nature. How nature and human are connected with each other that we observe  in this story.
       
•  Real Issue : 
              This work seems satire on the translocating of the Gir lions to Madhya Pradesh. Yes, there are some drawbacks which becomes the reason of lion's death. But main cause is the environmental change. There are some environmentalists who says that to keep them on a single place may be disastrous but there are more negative points in translocation. Like it may be detrimental to their breeding and survival.

• In short, story is about a girl named 'Sansai'. Who tells narrator ( A Painter - that we come to know at the end ) about her dream, that ' Ramjaana ' is not well. ( Name of Lioness !) While moving further 'Sansai' suffers from some kind of psychological trauma and as a result of it she roars/ yells. In the reply of it ' Aaima' Says " ખમા............. ને!" Which reminds us about Exorcism. Yes,  still these kinds of superstitions prevails in rural India.
           Phew ! but here story is different. Suddenly a lion cub comes and starts playing with her, and then leaves to the forest.

          In nutshell, one must should not interfere in the lives of animals, or in natural place. But yes,  writer deserves the praise because technique of story telling is an excellent one.

4 - ' Museum of Innocence ' : 

            Besides some serious stories this story is comparatively comic one. We can consider this story as a Didactical story too.

           When we start reading the story we feel humour in every dialogues. But suddenly Pinteresque style comes in our mind. Because there are so many dialogues which has deep meanings in it.

~  Envelope / Paper / Letter  : From the starting of the story this letter remains in the center. (Don't forget the story 'The Purloined Letter' by Poe !) Don't worry this story is totally different. As we all know that an envelope always creates so many assumption. As in the story people assumes that "Police no dakho hashe," "Light bill baaki lage se (chhe)," and "Kaagal khota gamama aavi gyo se (chhe)," {thanks to Google Map } etc. It looks  humorous but if the situation is real then what we will do...?  For example , you have paid the electric bill but yet you get fined through this letter then what will you do..?  You receives letter late, you can't filed a petition because dates are gone....Now think?


         Fortunately this letter is different. Here Sarpanch of the village ( Sanosra ) receives this letter from Istanbul. They wants some " Innocence " for museum. What a creativity !

• The Dying Humanity / Increasing of Violence : 

         Day by day we find the increasing level of violence.  And as a result of it,  "Istanbul"  wants to built a museum of "innocence." Because it seems that innocence will die soon... As in the story people are not able to find the innocence. But what they say is : "આઘડીએ ખાટકી વસ્તુ ગોતવાનુ કયો લ્યો. ગાડેે ગાડા ભરી દઈએ ! "

Banyan Tree : 

        In the story people doesn't find any "innocence" in the village.  After a while "Kadavima" shows the innocence in the form of that banyan tree. Here banyan tree represent the firmness, holiness,  altruism and, etc.




Why " Istanbul " ....? 

           Yes, why only Istanbul...?  mainly it is famous for natural harbor and as a connecting nation of Europe and Asia , or it represents anything else...?
(Wikipedia)

• Rustic Language : 

           Almost whole story is in rustic language. As it represents the social connotation.

• " નાડાછડી  અને સૂતરનો ત્રાગડો " : 

            At the end of the story narrator mentions these words.  Which is connected to the rituals as a sacred / protective thread. But what we get from it is we need to protect Humanity so we can establish peace.... 



           Apart from all these stories,on  his visit he talked about translation studies. Where, In funny way he satired on poor condition of the B. A. course. He used a word: 'Academic Dalit.'
               In addition he discussed various approaches which he has used in his stories. How building a hypothesis about creating a story helps in giving more effect. Meanwhile,  he gave some important tips to ponder over.  Like, how to develop an interest in writing translation,  one needs to do deep reading,  English usage,  How to put surprise element in story,  research perspective in translation studies and etc. 
             In nutshell he discussed various myths related to translations and also gave some good examples of translation.  Like "Sudharo" : Civilization not reform, "Daam Devo" : Cauterize not burning bar on back. Thus,  we came to know about how well dictionary you needs in translations. Further he gave a feedback paper in which students had to translate the paragraph. Overall it was wonderful session to attend.
          At last I would like to thanks  Dr Dilip Barad Sir for making us aware about these kinds of stories. Most importantly it helps reader in developing the imagination power and thinking ability too.

                                                    Thank you ...
                                                    Courtesy ...